Blog #3

Topic: 
The Oregon Trail
National Standards Bundle: 
  • Theme #2 Time Continuity and Change -- Processes: Evaluate the impact of the values, beliefs, and institutions of people in the past on important historical decisions and developments of their times. 
  • D2.Geo.7.3-5. Explain how cultural and environmental characteristics affect the distribution and movement of people, goods, and ideas. 
Bundle Defense: Because theme 2 is a history standard and the dimension is a geography standard, students will likely not be repetitive in their thinking. The theme asks students to evaluate the impact of values, beliefs, and institutions while the dimension supports how the environment affects the decisions made to move west. 

Compelling Question: What aspects of the environment helped shape their decision to move west on the Oregon Trail?

Compelling Question Defense: It could be considered relevant to students because of where we are geographically located (near the Oregon Trail). Evidence can be used to back up students' answers. There are multiple ways to answer this question, and it can be easily enhanced with supporting questions.


    To further my own and my future students thinking about this compelling question, and to keep my students on track when discovering the answer to the compelling question that has been proposed, supporting questions will be necessary. A few supporting questions I came up with include:
  • What path did the Oregon Trail follow (where exactly was it located)?
  • What are a few different aspects of the environment in which we live (on the west coast)?
  • Is the environment something you would take in consideration when deciding where to live for the rest of your life?
Following on the track of these supporting questions and the compelling question being proposed, my answer would include the fact they moved west because there was a possibility of finding gold which would've fixed their economic problems, as well as talk of free land which would be useful for them as well to farm/start a completely new life. 



Comments

  1. Hi Tabatha,
    I think your defense of your compelling question is great! I remember how much we really focused on the Oregon Trail since we live so close to it. I think your supporting questions matched really well. I like your second question specifically, it would have them explore why coming to the west coast was so desirable. I think it would also be beneficial if you added or replaced one of the other questions with one about what conditions they faced. Which would prompt the answer of the rewards being greater than the risk, or they could decide that it wouldn't have been worth it to them.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It's a great idea to include a question about the conditions they faced, I agree! Especially because my compelling question had to do with the aspects of the environment.

      Delete
  2. Hi Tabatha,
    I think you did a great job choosing a standards bundle. The community change over time and movement of cultures mesh well together. The defense was strong using geography was a great choice along with the Oregon trail. The first standard being focused on historical decision making compliments the culture standard well. Great job creating the compelling question felt strongly in line with your bundle. Great post!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you! The worry about making them too closely related took up a lot of my groups time when writing this one, so I'm glad we finally figured out a good one in the end.

      Delete
  3. Hey Tabatha,
    I enjoyed your compelling question. Made me think back and remember what I learned in school and trying to remember the trail that they picked and why. Now my brain is trying to remember more about the travels that they made and the many hardships that they had.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This is how I felt about it -- I often find myself pondering these questions myself as if I didn't already learn them in my school days.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Blog #2

Blog Reflection #1